Where We Buy · Ohio · Carroll County

Sell your Carroll County mineral rights.

Carrollton, Malvern, Dellroy: the original Utica boom county, number one in Ohio oil, and the place where 2010 era lease terms matter more than geology.

Carroll County was the epicenter of the original Utica boom in 2011 through 2013, went quiet as operators chased dry gas east, and has come back. It is now first in Ohio for oil at roughly 4.1 million barrels a quarter, about 36 percent of the state total, driven by Encino and now EOG drilling the volatile oil window with modern completions.

But geology is not the main question here. Lease terms are. Carroll holds the oldest Utica leases in the play, signed in 2010 through 2012 before anyone understood the rock, frequently at 12.5 to 15 percent with poor deduction language and no Pugh clause. A great many are held by production from a first generation well while the surrounding acreage is being redeveloped today. Whether that old instrument still holds all your depths and all your acreage turns on the specific habendum, Pugh, and depth clauses, and early Utica lease validity litigation originated in this county.

So we read the lease before we quote a number, and we tell you what we think it holds and what it does not. That analysis is free and it is yours whether or not you sell to us.

EOG Ohio is the dominant operator with roughly 516 active wells, following its Encino acquisition, alongside Infinity Natural Resources. Roughly 608 wells are active out of 4,000 drilled.

And as everywhere in Ohio, if nothing has been recorded in your name in decades, the Dormant Mineral Act and the Marketable Title Act both put your interest at risk. Record a claim to preserve first.

Formations & Plays

What produces here

Utica and Point Pleasant, volatile oil and condensate window

Roughly 4.1 million barrels of oil in a recent quarter, about 36 percent of all Ohio oil and first in the state, plus about 37.2 million Mcf of gas.

Counties

Communities we see in Carroll County title

Carrollton Malvern Dellroy Magnolia Minerva Sherrodsville

Wherever your tract sits in Carroll County, we will research it free and value it with the work shown.

Questions

Straight answers for Carroll County owners

My Carroll County lease is from 2011 and pays one eighth. Am I stuck with it?
That is the central question in this county, and it is worth real money to answer properly. Carroll holds the oldest Utica leases in the play, signed in 2010 through 2012 before anyone understood what was underneath, frequently at 12.5 to 15 percent with weak deduction language and no Pugh clause. Many are held by production from a first generation well while the acreage is now being redeveloped with modern completions. Whether that old lease still holds all depths and all acreage depends on its specific habendum, Pugh, and depth clauses. We read them, and early Utica lease validity litigation originated in this county.
Is Carroll County declining?
No, it was revived. Carroll was the original 2011 to 2013 Chesapeake Utica boom county, went quiet mid decade as operators chased dry gas to the east, and has been brought back by Encino and now EOG drilling the oil window with modern completions. It is now first in Ohio for oil at roughly 4.1 million barrels a quarter, about 36 percent of the state total. Roughly 608 wells are active out of 4,000 drilled, with 2,600 permits on file.
Who operates here now?
EOG Ohio operates roughly 516 active wells, EOG Resources about 33, and Infinity Natural Resources about 59. EOG's position came through its acquisition of Encino Acquisition Partners, which closed in 2025 and changed the payor on a large number of division orders.
Free Valuation

Find out what your Carroll County minerals are worth.

Free, no obligation, and no pressure. We reply within one business day, usually faster.

Prefer the phone? Call or text 918-984-1645 and you will get Stephen, the owner, not a call center. If we miss you, we text back the same day.

No cost, no obligation, and we never share your information.

Call Text Free Valuation